cardiac physical examination
in review
7 min read
Updated 2026-10-19
cardiac physical examination
Findings are likelihood ratios on a pretest probability (mostly cardiologist examiners, high-prevalence cohorts). Slow carotid upstroke, late-peaking murmur, soft S2 rule in AS; no murmur to the right carotid rules it out. S3 (LR ~11) and raised JVP (~5) rule in HF; pulsus ≤10 mmHg nearly excludes tamponade. Manoeuvres change preload and afterload — predict the murmur from the physiology.
how murmurs change with manoeuvres
| manoeuvre | haemodynamic effect | louder | softer |
|---|---|---|---|
| quiet inspiration; sustained RUQ abdominal pressure | ↑ venous return to right heart | right-sided: TR, pulmonary stenosis | — |
| Valsalva (strain 20 s) or squat → stand | ↓ preload (Valsalva also ↑ afterload) | HCM (LVOT obstruction); MVP click moves earlier | AS |
| stand → squat; passive leg raise to 45° | ↑ venous return and ↑ afterload | — | HCM, MVP |
| transient arterial occlusion (both arm cuffs 20–40 mmHg above SBP, 20 s) | ↑ afterload | left-sided regurgitation: MR, VSD, AR | — |
- HCM: smaller LV cavity (↓ preload) or stronger squeeze → more SAM → louder; bigger cavity → softer. Murmur ↓ with passive leg raise: LR+ 8.0, LR− 0.22. Standing → squatting: murmur ↓ or unchanged LR+ 4.5; murmur ↑ LR 0.13 → hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
- AS murmur softens with Valsalva (↓ flow); Valsalva doesn’t help diagnose AS (LR+ 1.2)
- right-sided murmurs: ↑ with quiet inspiration — LR+ 8.0, LR− 0.0 for a right-sided valve lesion; to separate TR from MR, ↑ on inspiration LR+ ∞ (LR− 0.20); ↑ with abdominal pressure LR+ ∞ (LR− 0.33). Don’t ask for deep breaths (breath sounds mask the murmur)
- transient arterial occlusion rules in left-sided regurgitation (MR or VSD: LR+ 7.5, LR− 0.28; AR: LR+ 8.4, LR− 0.3)
- coach normal breathing; listen at the edge of radiation for an increase, at maximal intensity for a decrease
systolic murmurs
| location of maximal intensity | radiation | typical lesion |
|---|---|---|
| 2nd right intercostal space | right carotid, right clavicle | aortic stenosis |
| 5th–6th left ICS, mid-thorax (apex) | left axilla | mitral regurgitation (incl. MVP) |
| lower left sternal border | lower right sternal border, epigastrium | tricuspid regurgitation |
| 5th left ICS, mid-thorax / LLSB | lower left sternal border | HCM |
- grade 1 faint; 2 soft; 3 loud; 4 thrill
- cardiologist calls it normal → LR 0.0–0.3 for structural disease; bedside agreement for any murmur only fair (κ 0.30)
- flow murmurs with normal valves: anaemia, thyrotoxicosis, sepsis, volume overload in renal failure
aortic stenosis
| finding | LR+ | LR− |
|---|---|---|
| slow rate of rise of carotid pulse | 2.8–130 | 0.18–0.73 |
| mid-to-late peaking murmur | 8.0–101 | 0.13–0.31 |
| soft or absent S2 | 3.1–50 | 0.36–0.45 |
| brachioradial delay | 6.8 | 0.0 |
| apical–carotid delay | (2.4–∞) | 0.05 |
| S4 | 2.5 | 0.26 |
| reduced carotid volume | 2.2–2.3 | 0.31–0.39 |
| any systolic murmur | 2.4 | 0.0 |
| radiation to right carotid | 1.4–1.5 | 0.05–0.10 |
| effort syncope | ∞ | 0.76 |
- rule out: no murmur, or a murmur that doesn’t reach the right carotid
- rule in: slow upstroke, late peak, soft S2
- carotid: normal = sharp tap; slow rise = a nudge (or weak tap then a push); brachioradial delay = palpable lag between brachial and radial pulses
- → aortic stenosis
mitral regurgitation, MVP, TR
- MR: apical murmur LR+ 3.6–3.9 (LR− 0.12–0.34); late/holosystolic LR+ 1.8 (LR− 0.0) → no apical murmur makes moderate–severe MR unlikely, except acute MR after MI (absent murmur LR 0.66)
- MVP: mid-systolic click ± late systolic murmur — click and murmur LR+ 19 (cardiologists) vs 2.4 (non-cardiologists); standing moves the click earlier; no click and no murmur LR 0.04–0.26
- TR: holosystolic at LLSB, ↑ with inspiration; cardiologist-detected TR murmur LR+ 10, LR− 0.41
- house staff detect MR murmurs poorly (LR+ 1.1–4.6) → echo → valvular heart disease
diastolic murmurs
- AR: early diastolic decrescendo, left sternal border 3rd–4th ICS, sitting forward in expiration. Typical murmur LR+ 8.8–32 (mild+), 4.0–8.3 (moderate+); absence LR 0.1–0.3. Peripheral signs (wide pulse pressure, Corrigan, Duroziez, pistol-shot femorals, de Musset) are insensitive and don’t grade severity
- mitral stenosis: mid-diastolic rumble at the apex (bell, left lateral) — found in all 31 cases and no false positives in one nursing-home study
- pulmonary regurgitation: typical murmur raises likelihood; absence doesn’t lower it (LR 0.9)
- early diastolic murmur in a volume-overloaded dialysis patient → re-examine after fluid removal (often transient PR)
heart sounds and extra sounds
- S2: should be louder than S1 at the base; soft or absent → AS
- S3 (early diastolic, ventricular filling): LR+ 11 (57 in patients with lung disease) for heart failure in the dyspnoeic ED patient; LR− 0.88 → specific, insensitive
- S4 (pre-systolic, atrial kick into a stiff LV; bell, left lateral): AS, HCM, hypertension — absent in AF
- ejection sound 40–60 ms after S1 (aortic/pulmonary valve), fixed with posture; mid-systolic click later (MVP), earlier on standing
- HCM: harsh crescendo–decrescendo murmur, prominent apical impulse, abnormal carotid pulse, S4; nonobstructive HCM may have a normal exam
JVP and central venous pressure
- right internal jugular, head supported, trunk 30–45° (higher if very raised); sternal angle ~5 cm above mid-RA in any position → CVP ≈ JVP + 5 cm; upper normal JVP 4 cm (CVP 9 cmH₂O)
- venous (vs carotid): biphasic, impalpable, obliterable, falls with inspiration and sitting up, rises with abdominal pressure
- accuracy vs catheter: clinical “high” CVP LR 4.1, “low” CVP LR 3.4 for low; “normal” is uninformative (LR ~1); estimates vary by up to 7 cm between examiners
- abdominojugular reflux: firm mid-abdominal pressure 15–30 s, normal breathing (no Valsalva); sustained rise ≥4 cm = positive → right-sided overload; LR+ 6.4 for HF in the ED (one study, n=51, CI crosses 1)
| waveform | seen in |
|---|---|
| absent a wave | AF |
| large a wave | TS, pulmonary hypertension, PS, RA myxoma |
| cannon a wave | AV dissociation (complete heart block, VT) |
| large cv wave | TR |
| rapid (brisk) y descent | constrictive pericarditis, severe right HF, ASD |
| slow y descent | TS, RA myxoma |
| absent y descent | cardiac tamponade |
heart failure in the dyspnoeic patient
- S3 (LR+ 11) and raised JVP (5.1) rule in (abdominojugular reflux 6.4, single small study); no sign rules out — crackles absent LR 0.51; BNP <100 pg/mL LR 0.11
- full table (history, signs, CXR, ECG, BNP) → heart failure — diagnosis & classification
pericardial disease
- tamponade sensitivity: dyspnoea ~88%, tachycardia 77%, pulsus 82%, raised JVP 76%, CXR cardiomegaly 89%; hypotension 26%, quiet heart sounds 28%. Beck’s triad is acute surgical tamponade — often absent in slow medical effusions
- pulsus paradoxus with an effusion: >10 mmHg LR 3.3 (>12 mmHg LR 5.9); ≤10 mmHg LR 0.03 → tamponade unlikely (one study, n=65)
- measure: deflate slowly; pulsus = first Korotkoff sounds (expiration only) minus continuous sounds; masked by hypotension, adhesions, AR, ASD, RV hypertrophy, loculated effusion
- JVP: absent y descent in tamponade; brisk y descent in constriction; Kussmaul sign (JVP rises on inspiration) points to constriction (or severe right HF) — uncommon in pure tamponade (sens 26%); pericardial rub in ≤⅓ of pericarditis
- → pericardial effusion, tamponade and constriction, acute pericarditis
peripheral arterial disease
| finding | setting | LR+ | LR− |
|---|---|---|---|
| claudication | screening | 3.3 | 0.57 (moderate–severe) |
| femoral bruit | screening | 4.8 | 0.83 |
| any pulse abnormality | screening | 3.1 | 0.48 |
| cool skin | symptomatic | 5.9 | 0.92 |
| wounds or sores | symptomatic | 5.9 | 0.98 |
| ≥1 bruit (iliac, femoral, popliteal) | symptomatic | 5.6 | 0.39 |
| any pulse abnormality | symptomatic | 4.7 | 0.38 |
- no single finding rules PAD in or out → ABI → peripheral arterial disease; dissection → aortic dissection; syncope → syncope
Prepared 2026-10-19. Not yet verified — check every number against the sources.