immune checkpoint inhibitors
Contents
comparison
| Anti-PD-1 | Anti-PD-L1 | Anti-CTLA-4 | Anti-LAG-3 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agents | pembrolizumab, nivolumab, cemiplimab, dostarlimab | atezolizumab, durvalumab, avelumab | ipilimumab, tremelimumab | relatlimab |
| Mechanism | blocks PD-1 on T cells → prevents tumour PD-L1 from switching T cells off | blocks PD-L1 on tumour/APC → same effect from the ligand side | blocks CTLA-4 → enhances T-cell priming and activation (earlier in immune response) | blocks LAG-3 on T cells → similar to PD-1 blockade, restores exhausted T cells |
| Toxicity profile | moderate - pneumonitis, thyroiditis, hepatitis | similar to anti-PD-1 | highest toxicity - colitis, hypophysitis; grade ≥3 irAEs ~20–30% monotherapy, ~40–55% in combination with anti-PD-1 | similar to anti-PD-1 |
| Typical use | broadest indications: first-line across most solid tumours | NSCLC (durvalumab post-CRT), urothelial, TNBC | melanoma, RCC; almost always combined with anti-PD-1 | melanoma (combined with nivolumab) |
administration
- IV infusion 30–60 min; no routine premedication (no antiemetics or steroids); infusion reactions uncommon (~1–2%)
- no renal or hepatic dose adjustments as antibodies cleared by catabolism
- no myelosuppression: fever on ICI monotherapy is not neutropenic fever; think infection vs irAE (or, if on chemo-immunotherapy, the chemo)
- avoid systemic corticosteroids at ICI initiation (prednisone ≤10 mg/day or physiologic replacement is acceptable): baseline steroids may blunt anti-tumour response. When steroids are needed to treat irAEs, give them — toxicity management takes priority
- treatment typically continues up to 2 years or until progression/toxicity; responses are often durable, persisting after discontinuation
A minority of patients show apparent radiographic growth (immune infiltrate) before response. Uncommon (<10%), but a clinically well patient with early “progression” may continue with repeat imaging rather than stopping.
adverse effects — immune-related adverse events (irAEs)
All ICIs cause irAEs — see immune checkpoint inhibitor toxicity
Any new symptom in a patient on ICI is an irAE until proven otherwise.
| Class | Common irAEs | Distinguishing features |
|---|---|---|
| Anti-PD-1 / PD-L1 | thyroiditis (up to 20%), rash, hepatitis, pneumonitis | pneumonitis is the signature severe toxicity; thyroiditis often subclinical |
| Anti-CTLA-4 | diarrhoea (~30–40%), true colitis (~10–15%), hypophysitis (10–15%), rash, hepatitis | colitis is the signature toxicity — can be severe/perforating; any diarrhoea on ipilimumab needs investigation. Hypophysitis relatively specific to CTLA-4 blockade |
| Anti-LAG-3 | similar to anti-PD-1 | no unique toxicity signal |
| Combination (PD-1 + CTLA-4) | all of the above at higher rates | grade ≥3 in ~40–55%; earlier onset; more multi-organ toxicity |
Common nuisance irAEs — fatigue, arthralgia, pruritus/rash — are frequent and usually manageable without stopping treatment.
timing
- most irAEs present weeks 6–12 of treatment
- skin and GI (colitis) tend to be earlier; hepatic, pulmonary, and endocrine later
- irAEs can present months after discontinuation
high-risk irAEs to know
- myocarditis: rare (<1%) but up to 50% mortality; troponin + new conduction abnormality → ICU, pulse steroids. Often part of an overlap syndrome with myositis and myasthenia gravis; check CK and screen for ptosis/bulbar weakness
- pneumonitis: low index of suspicion for all new dyspnoea on ICI, often need to treat as pneumonitis until proven otherwise
- neurological: myasthenia-like syndrome, GBS, encephalitis; rare but rapidly progressive
- nephritis: immune interstitial nephritis (rising creatinine on ICI often misattributed to contrast, NSAIDs, or PPI). Diagnosis often requires biopsy
- immune-mediated DKA: sudden autoimmune beta-cell destruction; lifelong insulin
- colitis: particularly with ipilimumab; can perforate
- hypophysitis: particularly with ipilimumab; immune destruction of the pituitary → panhypopituitarism; presents with fatigue, headache, visual changes, adrenal insufficiency
- adrenalitis: primary adrenal insufficiency from direct glandular destruction; unlike hypophysitis, ACTH is elevated
endocrine gland destruction
Steroids won’t restore the damaged gland; treatment will involve lifelong hormone replacement.
| Gland destroyed | Replacement |
|---|---|
| Thyroid (thyroiditis → hypothyroidism) | levothyroxine |
| Pituitary (hypophysitis) | hydrocortisone + levothyroxine ± testosterone/oestrogen ± desmopressin |
| Adrenal (adrenalitis) | hydrocortisone ± fludrocortisone |
| Pancreatic beta cells (immune DKA) | insulin |
Both hypophysitis (secondary) and adrenalitis (primary) lead to adrenal insufficiency. Check AM cortisol and ACTH before starting levothyroxine: thyroid replacement increases cortisol clearance and can precipitate adrenal crisis. Remember to educate patient on steroid sick day rules.
management principles
Severity is graded by CTCAE (organ-specific criteria): in broad strokes, · 1 = mild/asymptomatic · 2 = moderate, limits daily activities · 3 = severe, hospitalisation usually indicated · 4 = life-threatening.
- grade ≥3 → hold ICI + high-dose systemic corticosteroids (methylprednisolone 1–2 mg/kg/day; pulse for myocarditis); taper over ≥4–6 weeks once grade ≤1
- steroid-refractory (no improvement 48–72 h) → escalate to targeted immunosuppression — see immune checkpoint inhibitor toxicity
- endocrine irAEs: steroids do not reverse glandular destruction; definitive treatment is hormone replacement, and ICI can usually resume once stable on replacement
- rechallenge: generally not after grade 4 irAEs, most recurrent grade 3, or any myocarditis/severe neurological irAE; may be possible after grade 2 and endocrine irAEs
special populations
- pre-existing autoimmune disease: relative, not absolute, contraindication; flare risk ~30–50%, usually manageable. Decision depends on disease severity and cancer prognosis
- solid organ transplant: high risk of graft rejection (~40% in kidney transplant); ICI generally avoided unless no alternative; always involve the transplant team
- immunosuppressed patients (chronic steroids >10 mg prednisone, biologics): may blunt efficacy; optimise before starting if feasible
key points
- anti-PD-1 (pembrolizumab, nivolumab) are the backbone of modern immunotherapy and are used across most solid tumours; often combined with chemotherapy first-line (NSCLC, TNBC, gastric, oesophageal)
- anti-CTLA-4 (ipilimumab) is rarely used alone; combined with anti-PD-1 in melanoma, RCC, NSCLC; effective but substantially more toxic
- ICI → no myelosuppression, no premeds, no dose adjustments
- any new symptom on ICI is an irAE until proven otherwise; have low threshold to hold and investigate; irAEs can present months after discontinuation
- endocrine irAEs need replacement, not steroids; check cortisol/ACTH before levothyroxine
- caution in autoimmune disease, essentially contraindicated in most transplant recipients