immune checkpoint inhibitor toxicity
Contents
immune checkpoint inhibitors.
general principles
- irAEs can affect any organ system at any time during or after treatment — toxicities can emerge months after discontinuation
- any new symptom in a patient on or recently exposed to ICI is an irAE until proven otherwise
- typical onset weeks 6–12; skin and GI typically earlier, hepatic/pulmonary/endocrine later
- rule out infection before attributing symptoms to irAEs: collect infectious workup before high-dose steroids if feasible, but don’t delay steroids in an unstable patient
- severity graded 1–4 (CTCAE); grade ≥3 → hold immunotherapy, initiate high-dose corticosteroids, involve relevant subspecialty
- anti-CTLA-4 → higher rates of colitis, hypophysitis; anti-PD-1/PD-L1 → higher rates of pneumonitis, thyroiditis, hepatitis
- combination CTLA-4 + PD-1 → grade ≥3 irAEs in ~55%; earlier onset, greater severity, more multi-organ involvement
workup
Baseline before starting ICI: TSH/fT4, AM cortisol, LFTs, Cr, glucose/HbA1c, hepatitis B serology.
First-line workup for suspected irAE: CBC, lytes, Cr, LFTs, TSH/fT4, AM cortisol, glucose, CRP, cultures — plus organ-specific tests below.
organ-specific irAEs
| Organ | Presentation | Key workup | Management pearls |
|---|---|---|---|
| skin | maculopapular rash, pruritus, vitiligo | clinical assessment | grade 1–2: emollients, topical steroids, antihistamines; systemic steroids if severe |
| skin — SJS/TEN | diffuse painful rash + mucosal involvement (oral/ocular/genital) ± fever | urgent derm, skin biopsy | emergency — hold ICI, admit, urgent derm + ophtho; high-dose steroids |
| colitis | diarrhoea, abdominal pain, haematochezia; grade 3 = ≥7 stools/day over baseline | stool C. difficile, fecal calprotectin, CT abdomen, colonoscopy if grade ≥2 persistent or bleeding | hold ICI; IV methylprednisolone; steroid-refractory → infliximab (vedolizumab if high infection risk); exclude CMV colitis if refractory |
| hepatitis | often asymptomatic transaminase elevation; grade 2 ≈ ALT 3–5× ULN, grade 3 ≈ 5–20× ULN | hepatitis serologies, review other hepatotoxic drugs, RUQ US/MRCP to exclude mets/obstruction | hold ICI; high-dose steroids; steroid-refractory → mycophenolate (never infliximab — hepatotoxic) |
| pneumonitis | dyspnoea, cough, hypoxia; high risk in lung cancer/prior thoracic RT; new dyspnoea on ICI is pneumonitis until proven otherwise | CT chest preferred over CXR (ground-glass, organising pneumonia); bronchoscopy/BAL for grade ≥2–3 to exclude infection/lymphangitic spread | hold ICI; grade 2 = prednisone 1 mg/kg/day; grade 3–4 = IV methylprednisolone; reassess 24–72 h |
| thyroiditis | initial thyrotoxicosis → hypothyroidism | TSH, free T4 | thyrotoxic phase: supportive (beta-blockers); hypothyroid phase: levothyroxine replacement |
| hypophysitis | fatigue, headache, visual changes, adrenal insufficiency | MRI pituitary, AM cortisol, TSH, gonadotropins | high-dose steroids acutely; long-term hormone replacement often needed |
| adrenalitis | adrenal insufficiency without pituitary involvement (ACTH elevated) | AM cortisol, ACTH | hydrocortisone replacement |
| nephritis | AKI, sterile pyuria, proteinuria — often misattributed to contrast/NSAIDs/PPI | urinalysis, Cr, UPCR, renal biopsy if unclear | hold ICI; steroids |
| myocarditis | chest pain, dyspnoea, arrhythmia, new conduction abnormalities (BBB, AV block) | troponin, BNP, ECG, echo, cardiac MRI; CK for myositis overlap | hold ICI; admit ICU; urgent cardiology; pulse IV methylprednisolone (see below) |
| neurological | myasthenia-like syndrome, Guillain-Barré, encephalitis | CK, EMG/NCS, MRI, LP | hold ICI; high-dose steroids; IVIG or plasmapheresis |
| rheumatologic | inflammatory arthritis, PMR-like syndrome, sicca | clinical ± RF/CCP, inflammatory markers | NSAIDs, low-dose prednisone; often chronic and persists after ICI — rheumatology input; rarely requires stopping ICI |
| haematologic | autoimmune haemolytic anaemia, aplastic anaemia, HLH | CBC, reticulocytes, DAT, haptoglobin, ferritin, fibrinogen, triglycerides | hold ICI; steroids; haematology input |
Others: uveitis (red painful eye → ophtho), asymptomatic lipase elevation (common, does not require treatment unless clinical pancreatitis).
life-threatening irAEs
- immune-mediated myocarditis — mortality up to 50%; elevated troponin + new conduction abnormality (BBB, AV block) is the hallmark; conduction disease is the leading cause of death
- the fatal triad (the “3 M’s”) — myocarditis + myositis + myasthenia gravis can overlap; troponin elevation in any ICI patient with weakness is myocarditis until proven otherwise; screen for all three at presentation
- immune-mediated DKA — sudden autoimmune beta-cell destruction → new DKA without prior diabetes; lifelong insulin
- severe colitis — bloody diarrhoea, fever, or peritoneal signs; → risk of perforation; steroid-refractory → infliximab
- SJS/TEN — mucosal involvement + painful rash → hold ICI, admit, urgent derm
- myasthenic crisis / Guillain-Barré — respiratory failure risk → serial FVC/NIF, ICU monitoring
ICI myocarditis — why telemetry alone is unsafe
ICI myocarditis is fulminant and unpredictable; it can progress within hours from a stable-looking conduction abnormality to complete heart block, sustained VT, cardiogenic shock, and death.
Management:
- permanently discontinue ICI
- admit to ICU/monitored bed — continuous telemetry, pacing pads on, readiness for temporary transvenous pacing and mechanical circulatory support
- pulse IV methylprednisolone 1 g/day × 3–5 days → oral prednisone 1 mg/kg/day with slow taper over 6–12 weeks
- screen for the 3 M’s overlap — CK (myositis), bedside swallow/forced vital capacity (myasthenia); overlap worsens prognosis
- steroid-refractory (no improvement 24–48 h) → abatacept, ATG, mycophenolate, IVIG, or plasmapheresis; avoid infliximab if reduced LVEF
- urgent cardiology/cardio-oncology — serial troponin, ECG, echo; cardiac MRI when stable
ICI-induced type 1 diabetes and DKA
Abrupt autoimmune beta-cell destruction → insulin-deficient diabetes, often presenting as DKA. Unlike most irAEs, this is not steroid-responsive and the destruction is irreversible.
Management:
- hold ICI until DKA resolved and glucose stabilised (may restart once on stable insulin)
- treat DKA per standard protocol — IV fluids, insulin infusion, potassium repletion, glucose and gap monitoring
- urgent endocrinology — anticipate lifelong insulin; C-peptide and anti-GAD/IA-2 antibodies confirmatory
- corticosteroids have no role — they do not reverse beta-cell destruction and actively worsen hyperglycaemia
When both coexist, pulse methylprednisolone is mandatory for the cardiac toxicity but will dramatically worsen glycaemic control. Manage with aggressive insulin titration (often high-dose insulin infusion) alongside the steroids. Coordinate cardiology, endocrinology, and oncology simultaneously.
Never start levothyroxine until adrenal insufficiency has been excluded or treated. Thyroid hormone increases cortisol clearance and can precipitate a fatal adrenal crisis. Always check AM cortisol/ACTH before initiating levothyroxine in ICI patients.
management framework
| Grade | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 (mild/asymptomatic) | continue ICI with close monitoring |
| 2 (moderate, limits daily activities) | hold ICI; oral prednisone 0.5–1 mg/kg/day; subspecialty input |
| 3 (severe, hospitalisation usually indicated) | hold ICI; IV methylprednisolone 1–2 mg/kg/day; subspecialty consult |
| 4 (life-threatening) | permanently discontinue ICI; IV methylprednisolone ± additional immunosuppression |
Exceptions to the framework: endocrine irAEs (replacement, not steroids — see above); rheumatologic irAEs (often managed through continued ICI).
steroid safety checklist
- monitor glucose, BP, mental status
- PJP prophylaxis (TMP-SMX) if ≥4 weeks of high-dose steroids anticipated
- gastric mucosal protection (PPI)
- bone protection (calcium, vitamin D ± bisphosphonate)
steroid-refractory irAEs
- defined as no meaningful improvement after 48–72 hours of adequate corticosteroids (24–48 h for myocarditis)
- escalation is organ-specific: colitis → infliximab (vedolizumab if high infection risk); hepatitis → mycophenolate (never infliximab); pneumonitis → infliximab, mycophenolate, or IVIG; neurological → IVIG/plasmapheresis; myocarditis → abatacept, ATG (avoid infliximab if low LVEF); haematologic → IVIG, rituximab per haematology
- before infliximab: check hepatitis B serology (reactivation risk), exclude CMV in refractory colitis, consider TB risk
tapering and rechallenge
- wait for improvement to grade ≤1 before initiating taper
- taper over ≥4–6 weeks — rapid taper dramatically increases flare risk
- monitor the organ during taper: hepatitis → ALT/AST/bili/INR; pneumonitis → SpO₂, O₂ requirement; colitis → stool frequency, CRP, fecal calprotectin
- rechallenge depends on peak grade and cancer benefit: grade 4 generally precludes it; grade 2 and most resolved grade 3 non-cardiac/non-neuro irAEs are often rechallenged with close monitoring
- endocrine exception: ICI can typically resume once stable on hormone replacement
- permanent discontinuation regardless of grade: myocarditis, severe neurological toxicity, severe hepatitis, SJS/TEN