diverticular disease
Clinical diagnosis of left-sided diverticulitis is right only 40–65% of the time → CT with IV contrast whenever the diagnosis is uncertain (ACP), which includes most first episodes and any severe presentation. Uncomplicated (wall thickening, fat stranding) in an immunocompetent patient without systemic features → outpatient, without antibiotics (ACP, AGA, ASCRS, WSES all agree), with clear fluids and review within a week. Antibiotics for immunocompromise, frailty or comorbidity, CRP >140, WBC >15, vomiting, or abscess. Abscess: small → antibiotics; >3 cm (ASCRS; WSES says 4–5 cm) → percutaneous drainage. Diffuse peritonitis → surgery. Colonoscopy 6–8 weeks after a complicated episode unless recent (ACP, ASCRS; AGA adds a first uncomplicated episode). No mesalamine for prevention (ACP strong). Elective resection after an abscess, fistula, stricture, or persistent / frequently recurring disease, by shared decision; not by episode count or young age.
classify on CT, then treat
flowchart TD
A[LLQ pain ± fever, ↑CRP/WBC] --> B[CT abdomen/pelvis with IV contrast]
B --> C{CT findings}
C -->|wall thickening, fat stranding only| D{immunocompetent, no sepsis, no high-risk feature?}
D -->|yes| E[outpatient, no antibiotics, review ≤7 days]
D -->|no| F[antibiotics, PO if possible]
C -->|pericolic gas or small abscess| G[admit, antibiotics]
C -->|abscess >3 cm| H[percutaneous drainage + antibiotics]
C -->|distant free gas without diffuse fluid| I[non-operative only if stable and closely watched]
C -->|diffuse peritonitis| J[emergency surgery]
- CT: sensitivity ~94%, specificity ~99% (ACP meta-analysis). ACP reserves it for diagnostic uncertainty; a patient with a typical recurrence and mild symptoms may not need it, but image anyone with signs of perforation, abscess or sepsis
- US by an expert is an acceptable first test (WSES; ASCRS also accepts US or MRI when CT is contraindicated, e.g. pregnancy), with CT if negative or equivocal. MRI if US is inconclusive and CT can’t be done (ACP); plain films only to look for free air or obstruction
- complicated = abscess, perforation, peritonitis, obstruction, stricture or fistula (~12% of presentations). Most complicated disease is the first episode; risk of complication falls with recurrences, except fistula
- Hinchey stages (I pericolic abscess → IV faecal peritonitis) are surgical; WSES uses a CT-based grade. None predicts outcome clearly better, so describe the CT findings
uncomplicated diverticulitis: antibiotics are optional
Evidence (ACP, ASCRS 1A, WSES, AGA all endorse it for selected patients): two RCTs of observation vs antibiotics in CT-proven uncomplicated diverticulitis, pooled in an individual-patient meta-analysis (van Dijk, Br J Surg. 2020) (n=1109): no significant difference at 1 year in ongoing disease (7.2 vs 5.0%), recurrence (8.6 vs 9.6%), complicated diverticulitis (4.0 vs 2.1%) or resection (5.0 vs 2.5%). Antibiotics didn’t help the higher-risk subgroups either (pain >7/10, WBC >13.5, previous episode).
- caveat: the trend favours antibiotics for complication and resection, and the analysis can’t exclude a ~2% absolute difference. Both trials excluded sepsis and immunosuppression, and one excluded prior episodes
- observe: immunocompetent, tolerating fluids, pain controlled at home, no systemic inflammation. Clear fluids for comfort, advance as tolerated; reassess within 7 days, sooner if worse; return if unable to eat after 3–5 days
- treat with antibiotics (AGA): immunocompromised, frail or major comorbidity, refractory pain or vomiting, CRP >140 mg/L, WBC >15 (ACP lists >13.5), symptoms >5 days, recent antibiotics (ACP), or fluid collection / long inflamed segment on CT (each predicts progression; baseline risk ~5%)
- regimen: PO whenever possible (WSES strong): amoxicillin-clavulanate, or ciprofloxacin + metronidazole, 4–7 days. Immunocompromised: broader, 10–14 days, early surgical input. IV regimens → intra-abdominal infections
- outpatient care is the default (ACP): no evidence that admission helps uncomplicated disease. Admit if unable to take fluids, complicated disease, immunosuppression, sepsis, unstable comorbidity, or failed outpatient care
- short courses are enough: 4 days of IV antibiotics was as good as 7 in an RCT (ASCRS)
complicated diverticulitis
| CT finding | management | strength |
|---|---|---|
| pericolic gas | antibiotics, non-operative trial | WSES weak |
| small abscess (≤3 cm; WSES <4–5 cm) | antibiotics alone; duration → intra-abdominal infections | WSES weak (ASCRS implied) |
| abscess >3 cm (ASCRS) or ≥4–5 cm (WSES) | percutaneous drainage + antibiotics; antibiotics alone if drainage unavailable and patient stable | ASCRS strong (>3 cm); WSES weak |
| distant free gas, no diffuse fluid | non-operative only in selected stable patients with close follow-up | WSES weak, very low certainty |
| diffuse peritonitis | surgery: Hartmann’s if critically ill or comorbid; primary anastomosis ± diverting stoma if stable; damage control if unstable | WSES strong for Hartmann’s in critically ill |
- large abscesses fail on antibiotics alone (up to 34% above 3 cm, ASCRS) because penetration is poor. The 3 vs 4–5 cm cut-off is a guideline difference, not settled evidence; a 3–4 cm abscess is a judgement call with IR
- after source control: 4 days of antibiotics
- right-sided diverticulitis: same principles
after the episode
colonoscopy
- after a complicated episode: colonoscopy at 6–8 weeks or after full recovery, if none recently (ACP conditional, ASCRS strong, AGA). AGA defers if a high-quality colonoscopy was done within 1 year; ACP considers longer intervals reasonable
- complicated disease carries ~6× the cancer prevalence of uncomplicated (ACP review; most cancers found were in complicated cases)
- pooled cancer prevalence after diverticulitis ~1.9%: 7.9% after complicated vs 1.3% after uncomplicated (meta-analysis of 31 studies). A colonic “abscess” can be a perforated cancer
- after uncomplicated disease the guidelines split: ACP (uncomplicated or recurrent episodes don’t justify extra colonoscopy if screening is up to date) and WSES don’t recommend routine colonoscopy; AGA advises it after a first episode. Sensible default: colonoscopy after any complicated episode, any alarm feature (iron deficiency, bleeding, weight loss, change in stool calibre), or a first episode in someone not up to date with screening
- recurrent uncomplicated episodes → routine screening intervals → cancer screening — Canadian guidelines
recurrence and surgery
- recurrence: ~8% at 1 year and ~20% at 10 years after a first episode; after a second episode, 18% at 1 year and 55% at 10 years; ~25% at 5 years after an abscess treated without surgery
- elective resection is not decided by the number of episodes or by young age (AGA, WSES, ASCRS). Recommend it for fistula, obstruction or stricture (ASCRS strong); consider it after an abscess treated without surgery (ASCRS strong) and in immunosuppression. Discuss it for persistent (>3 months) or frequently recurring (≥3 in 2 years) uncomplicated disease affecting quality of life (ACP conditional)
- resection reduces but doesn’t abolish recurrence (15% vs 61% at 5 years in one trial), and 22–25% still have chronic pain afterwards
- chronic symptoms after diverticulitis (~45% at 1 year): exclude smouldering inflammation, stricture, IBD or ischaemic colitis with CT + colonoscopy; most is visceral hypersensitivity → reassurance, low-dose TCA → irritable bowel syndrome
prevention
- high-fibre diet pattern, normal BMI, physical activity, no smoking; avoid regular non-aspirin NSAIDs (continue cardiac ASA); opioids and corticosteroids raise the risk of perforation
- nuts, seeds and popcorn are fine
- no mesalamine (ACP strong, high certainty: no reduction in recurrence at 1.2–4.8 g/day); probiotics and rifaximin not recommended for recurrence (AGA; ASCRS weak, “not typically”, may help chronic symptoms)
- ASCRS strong: stop smoking, less red meat, exercise, weight loss
- ~40–50% of the risk is genetic
Undifferentiated abdominal pain → approach to acute abdominal pain. Diverticular bleeding (painless, large volume, usually not with diverticulitis) → lower GI bleeding.
Prepared 2026-11-19. Not yet verified — check every number against the sources.