death determination and organ donation

in review 5 min read Updated 2026-10-29
death determination and organ donation

Canada (2023) uses one brain-based definition of death: permanent loss of consciousness and of brainstem function, including breathing. It is reached either circulatory (DCC) (arterial pulse pressure <5 mmHg, watched 5 min controlled / 10 min uncontrolled) or neurologic (DNC) (established cause on imaging + confounders excluded → coma, absent brainstem reflexes, apnoea test). One complete DNC exam suffices in adults. DNC needs core temperature ≥36 °C and, after cardiac arrest without devastating imaging, a 48 h wait. Apnoea test positive when PaCO₂ ≥60 and ≥20 above baseline with pH ≤7.28. Devastating brain injury: observe in ICU before withdrawing, and refer to the organ donation organisation before withdrawal of life-sustaining measures.


neurologic criteria (DNC)

prerequisites

  • established cause of devastating brain injury severe enough to cause death, supported by neuroimaging
  • timing after cardiac arrest: wait ≥48 h from ROSC for hypoxic-ischaemic injury unless imaging already shows devastating injury (conditional). Arrest secondary to a primary catastrophe (TBI, massive stroke, ICH) with oedema or herniation on imaging → 24 h may suffice
  • confounders excluded:
confounderrequirement
temperaturecore ≥36 °C (oesophageal, bladder, rectal, intravascular). After TTM or exposure ≤34 °C → wait 24 h after rewarming
BPSBP ≥100 or MAP ≥60 (pressors as needed)
drugs5 elimination half-lives (longer with infusions, renal/hepatic failure, obesity, hypothermia), or supratherapeutic levels excluded; ethanol ≤17 mmol/L
neuromuscular blockadetrain-of-four or deep tendon reflexes present
metabolic/endocrinecorrect severe derangements (Na⁺, glucose, PO₄, Mg, thyroid, liver/renal failure); if uncorrectable and plausibly contributing → ancillary test. Ontario (TGLN checklist, labs within 4–6 h): Na⁺ 125–159, PO₄ >0.4, glucose 3–30 mmol/L, pH 7.30–7.50, PaCO₂ <60 before testing, urea <40, creatinine <400 (eGFR >30), bilirubin <100; outside these → call the Donation Support Physician
local factorsfacial/ocular trauma, high spinal cord injury, severe neuromuscular disease (GBS, ALS), decompressive craniectomy → ancillary test or more time

Reported reversible mimics: botulism, rabies encephalitis, diffuse leptomeningeal carcinomatosis.

clinical assessment

All three must be absent:

  1. consciousness: no response to central (supraorbital) or peripheral pain; spinal reflexes can persist and don’t exclude death
  2. brainstem reflexes: pupils fixed (clinical or pupillometry), corneal, vestibulo-ocular (cold calorics), gag, cough on suction, facial grimace to pain. No oculocephalic (doll’s eye) testing (strong): it adds nothing to cold calorics
  3. breathing: apnoea test
  • one complete assessment is sufficient in adults (≥1 year). Ontario, for donation: two physicians must each confirm death; legal time of death = completion of the first physician’s last required test (TGLN)
  • the physician must have no involvement in transplantation or the recipient’s care
  • isolated infratentorial (brainstem/posterior fossa) injury without supratentorial involvement → clinical exam plus mandatory ancillary test (a brainstem-only lesion can leave the cortex perfused)

apnoea test

  • pre-oxygenate and get a baseline ABG; aim for normocapnia before starting
  • disconnect with CPAP or passive O₂ via catheter in the ETT; watch the chest and abdomen for any breath
  • serial ABGs. Positive (no breathing) when PaCO₂ ≥60 mmHg and ≥20 above baseline, with pH ≤7.28
  • high risk of instability, or an aborted test (hypotension, desaturation, arrhythmia): halve minute ventilation beforehand to raise baseline PaCO₂, or use exogenous CO₂
  • chronic CO₂ retainers: thresholds unreliable → ancillary test if in doubt

ancillary tests

When: the clinical exam can’t be completed, a confounder can’t be resolved, movements are hard to interpret, isolated infratentorial injury, or the family asks.

  • use (absent brain blood flow): CT angiography, CT perfusion, transcranial Doppler, radionuclide lipophilic perfusion scan
  • don’t use: EEG, SSEP, BAEP, MRI, four-vessel angiography, lipophobic flow-only scan
  • ancillary tests support a valid exam; they cannot replace one or override an exam that shows function. Flow present → not dead; repeat later

circulatory criteria (DCC)

  • monitoring: continuous invasive arterial pressure. Arterial pulse pressure <5 mmHg = circulation stopped. ECG only if no reliable arterial line. Don’t use palpation, auscultation, Doppler or echo
  • return of ECG activity without pulse pressure >5 mmHg doesn’t restart the observation period
  • observation: 5 min continuous after circulatory arrest in controlled DCC (after withdrawal of life-sustaining measures or after MAiD); 10 min in uncontrolled DCC (unexpected arrest, failed CPR)
  • after declaration, organ-preservation interventions must not restore brain circulation

devastating brain injury and donation

  • devastating brain injury (TBI, SAH, ICH, stroke, anoxia) judged incompatible with survival or good recovery: early prognosis is often wrong, and the variation between centres in early withdrawal drives mortality
  • default: admit, support physiology and observe in ICU before withdrawing (Neurocritical Care Society recommends ~72 h; the optimal period isn’t established). Exceptions: care contrary to the patient’s known wishes, physiological futility, or comorbidity that would preclude ICU anyway
  • refer to the provincial organ donation organisation for every patient who is ventilated, has a grave prognosis with imminent death, and has withdrawal of life-sustaining measures under consideration. Refer before withdrawal; eligibility is the organisation’s call, not the bedside team’s
  • separate conversations: the treating team discusses prognosis and goals of care first (goals of care); the donation organisation leads the donation conversation
  • Ontario: designated hospitals must notify the agency (Ontario Health – Trillium Gift of Life Network) as soon as possible of every death and every imminent death, unless the agency’s own exemption criteria apply (Gift of Life Act s. 8.1). The agency, not the bedside team, decides whether the family is approached
  • donation after MAiD is controlled DCC: 5 min observation; arterial line by default, ECG acceptable if a line isn’t possible or the donor declines one → medical assistance in dying
  • DNC should be assessed in anyone who may meet criteria, whether or not donation is planned; it ends the obligation to ventilate
dead vs dying

DNC means death: there is no “brain dead but alive”, and life support is not “withdrawn” after DNC. Unresponsive wakefulness or a minimally conscious state, however profound, is not death. Any residual brainstem function excludes DNC.

Neuroprognostication after cardiac arrest (a different question: survival with function): post-cardiac arrest care.

Prepared 2026-10-29. Not yet verified — check every number against the sources.

Key references

+2 more sources

Suggest a correction death determination and organ donation